Dismissal During Probation

Can I Dismiss Someone During Their Probation Period, and What Process Should I Follow?

Taking on a new employee is always a bit of a leap of faith. You might have had a great interview, checked their references and felt confident they were the right person for your business.

But sometimes, once someone starts, things don’t quite work out as expected.

Perhaps their performance isn’t meeting the required standard, they’re making repeated mistakes, or they’re struggling to demonstrate the skills and behaviours the role requires.

For many SME owners, this raises an important question: can you dismiss someone during their probation period, or do you still need to follow a formal process?

With significant changes to unfair dismissal rights coming into force on 1 January 2027, it’s more important than ever for employers to understand their responsibilities.

Let’s break it down in plain English.

The Simple Answer

Yes, you can dismiss an employee during their probation period if things aren’t working out. However, being on probation doesn’t mean they have no employment rights or that you can dismiss them for any reason.

A probation period is an opportunity for both the employer and employee to assess whether the role is a good fit. It doesn’t remove your legal responsibilities as an employer.

In practice, this means:

  • Having a genuine, lawful reason for dismissal
  • Checking the employee’s contract and probation terms
  • Raising performance or conduct concerns early
  • Giving the employee an opportunity to respond
  • Following a fair and reasonable process
  • Providing the correct notice and final payments
  • Keeping appropriate records of your decision

The process may be simpler than dismissing a long-serving employee, but it still needs to be handled properly.

Important Changes from 1 January 2027

One of the biggest changes introduced by the Employment Rights Act 2025 is the reduction in the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal protection.

From 1 January 2027, employees will generally be able to claim ordinary unfair dismissal after six months’ continuous employment, rather than the current two years.

This change will also apply to existing employees who already have at least six months’ service when the new rules take effect.

For employers, particularly those operating six-month probation periods, this is an important development.

Once an employee has acquired ordinary unfair dismissal protection, the employer must be able to demonstrate a potentially fair reason for dismissal and that a fair and reasonable process has been followed.

Importantly, an employee does not have to have successfully completed probation to acquire these rights.

Employees with less than six months’ service will also continue to have protection against discrimination, certain automatically unfair reasons for dismissal and breaches of contract.

The changes also remove the existing statutory cap on compensatory awards for ordinary unfair dismissal, potentially increasing the financial consequences of getting a dismissal wrong.

The key message for employers is simple: don’t leave probation reviews until the last minute.

Step 1: Understand What a Probation Period Actually Means

Probation periods are commonly used when someone joins a business, often lasting three or six months.

They give employers time to assess whether the employee can perform the role, meet expectations and work effectively within the business.

However, there’s an important distinction to understand.

A probation period is a contractual arrangement, not a separate legal employment status. An employee doesn’t suddenly gain all their employment rights when they pass probation. Many rights apply from their first day.

There is no legal requirement to have a probation period, and the law does not prescribe how long one must last.

In light of the changes from January 2027, employers may wish to review their existing probation arrangements.

For example, a three-month probation period, with the option to extend for a further three months where appropriate, may provide a more structured opportunity to identify and address concerns.

However, extending probation beyond six months will not delay an employee acquiring ordinary unfair dismissal protection.

Ultimately, probation should be a meaningful assessment period, not simply a date in the diary.

Step 2: Check the Employment Contract

Before taking any action, look at what the employee’s contract says about probation.

You should check:

  • How long the probation period lasts
  • Whether the business can extend it
  • What notice period applies during probation
  • Whether there are specific review arrangements
  • What procedures or policies apply to dismissal

For example, some contracts provide for one week’s notice during probation, increasing once the employee has successfully completed it.

However, employers must still meet statutory minimum notice requirements where these apply.

An employee who has worked continuously for at least one month is generally entitled to a minimum of one week’s notice, unless they are being lawfully dismissed without notice for gross misconduct. A longer contractual notice period must also be honoured.

Employers should also be mindful that statutory notice provisions can affect the calculation of qualifying service, particularly where dismissal takes place close to the six-month threshold.

Don’t assume that because someone is on probation, you can simply ask them to leave immediately without checking their entitlements.

Step 3: Raise Concerns Early

One of the biggest mistakes employers make is waiting until the end of probation to tell someone that things aren’t working out.

If an employee is struggling, they should know what the concerns are and what they need to do differently.

For example, if someone is consistently missing deadlines, making errors or failing to meet expected standards, arrange a conversation rather than hoping the problem will resolve itself.

Explain:

  • What isn’t meeting expectations
  • What standard is required
  • What support or training is available
  • What improvement you need to see
  • When their progress will be reviewed

Keep a record of the discussion and any agreed actions.

Regular probation reviews, for example after one and three months, can help identify concerns before they become more serious.

With ordinary unfair dismissal rights reducing to six months, employers should be particularly careful not to allow performance concerns to drift without taking appropriate action.

Probation should be an active review process, not simply a meeting at the end to decide whether someone stays or goes.

Step 4: Give the Employee a Fair Opportunity

If performance or suitability remains a concern, give the employee an opportunity to explain their perspective before making a decision.

There may be circumstances you haven’t considered.

For example, perhaps they haven’t received the training they were promised, the role is different from what was advertised, or they’re dealing with a health condition that affects their work.

Where a disability may be involved, employers have a legal duty to consider reasonable adjustments.

You should also consider whether extending probation would be appropriate, particularly where the employee has shown improvement but needs more time.

An extension isn’t compulsory, and it should only be used where the contract permits it or the employee agrees.

If probation is extended, explain the reasons, the improvements required, the support available and the revised review date. Confirm the extension in writing.

Remember that an extension does not postpone statutory employment rights. An employee who reaches six months’ qualifying service will generally have ordinary unfair dismissal protection, even if they remain on probation.

The aim is to make an informed decision rather than a rushed one.

Step 5: Hold a Probation Review Meeting

If you’re considering dismissal, arrange a meeting with the employee to discuss the concerns and give them an opportunity to respond.

Explain the purpose of the meeting in advance, including that their continued employment may be at risk.

During the discussion:

  • Outline the concerns clearly and factually
  • Refer to previous conversations and agreed expectations
  • Explain what improvement has or hasn’t been achieved
  • Allow the employee to respond
  • Consider any relevant circumstances before reaching a decision

Employers should follow any applicable contractual procedures and consider whether a formal disciplinary or capability process is required.

Where a meeting could result in dismissal or formal disciplinary action, employers should consider the employee’s right to be accompanied, in accordance with the applicable Acas guidance. The statutory right may not apply to every probation review meeting, but employers can still offer accompaniment as good practice.

Employees should also be offered an opportunity to appeal a dismissal decision.

From January 2027, employers need to be particularly mindful that employees with six months’ qualifying service will generally have protection against ordinary unfair dismissal.

This means being able to demonstrate not only a fair reason for dismissal but also that a fair and reasonable process has been followed.

Remember, the meeting should be a genuine opportunity to discuss the situation, not simply a formality after you’ve already decided the outcome.

Step 6: Confirm the Decision in Writing

If you decide that dismissal is appropriate, confirm the outcome in writing.

Your letter should normally include:

  • Confirmation that employment is ending
  • The reason for the decision
  • The employee’s final working day and termination date
  • The notice period or payment in lieu of notice, where applicable
  • Details of outstanding salary and accrued but untaken holiday pay
  • Arrangements for returning company property
  • Information about the right of appeal and how to exercise it

Make sure the employee receives everything they’re legally and contractually entitled to.

It’s also important to keep copies of probation reviews, meeting notes, correspondence and the final decision.

Even where an employee has limited service, good documentation can help demonstrate that the decision was reasonable, consistent and unrelated to any unlawful reason.

A Practical Example

Imagine a small business takes on a new administrator with a three-month probation period.

After the first few weeks, the manager notices repeated errors, missed deadlines and difficulties completing routine tasks.

Rather than raising these concerns, the manager decides to wait until the end of probation.

At the three-month review, the employee is told that they haven’t passed probation and their employment is being terminated immediately.

The employee is understandably surprised. They hadn’t been told there were serious concerns, hadn’t received additional support and weren’t given an opportunity to improve.

Although the employer may have a legitimate reason for ending the employment, the situation could have been handled much better.

A more sensible approach would have been to raise the concerns early, explain the required improvements, offer appropriate support and review progress before deciding whether dismissal was necessary.

If the employee still couldn’t meet the required standards, the business would be in a much stronger position to explain and evidence its decision.

Now consider a slightly different situation.

The employer repeatedly extends probation without formally addressing performance concerns. By the time a decision is made, the employee has completed more than six months’ service.

From January 2027, that employee will generally have ordinary unfair dismissal protection, despite never having formally passed probation.

The employer will therefore need to demonstrate that the dismissal was substantively and procedurally fair.

This highlights why properly managed probation reviews and timely decisions are so important.

What Should Employers Have in Place?

To manage probation periods effectively and reduce the risk of disputes, make sure you have:

  • Clear probation terms in employment contracts
  • Defined expectations for new employees
  • A structured induction and training process
  • Regular probation review meetings
  • A process for raising concerns and recording improvements
  • Clear arrangements for extending probation where appropriate
  • A consistent and fair approach to dismissal decisions
  • Correct notice and final payment procedures
  • Access to professional HR advice when needed

For most SMEs, this doesn’t require a complicated HR system.

A straightforward process, applied consistently, can make a significant difference.

In Summary

Probation periods are a valuable way to assess whether a new employee is right for your business, but they shouldn’t be treated as a period where normal employment rules don’t apply.

You can dismiss someone during probation if there is a genuine, lawful reason, but the safest approach is to be clear about expectations, address concerns promptly and follow a fair, proportionate process.

With ordinary unfair dismissal rights reducing to six months from 1 January 2027, employers should take the opportunity to review how they manage probation periods.

Before making a decision, ask yourself:

  • Have I explained what isn’t working?
  • Has the employee had an opportunity to respond?
  • Have I provided appropriate support or training?
  • Have I checked the contract and notice requirements?
  • Could there be any discrimination or other legal concerns?
  • Can I demonstrate why the decision was made?
  • Have I considered whether the employee has acquired ordinary unfair dismissal protection?

If you’re unsure about any of these points, it’s worth getting advice before proceeding.

A well-managed probation process helps businesses make better recruitment decisions, supports employees who may simply need more guidance and reduces the likelihood of costly employment disputes.

Dismissal – Probation periods – Acas

Are Your Probation Procedures Ready for January 2027?

With significant changes to unfair dismissal rights approaching, now is a good time to review your employment contracts, probation procedures and performance management arrangements.

At JT HRConsultancy, we provide practical, straightforward HR advice to help businesses manage employee performance, probation reviews and dismissals fairly and confidently.

Whether you need help reviewing your existing procedures or advice about a particular employee, we’re here to help you make informed decisions and reduce unnecessary risk. Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures | JT HRConsultancy

Contact JT HRConsultancy to discuss how we can support your business.

 

 

Previous Post
Cart

No products in the cart.